November 19, 2026

Whole Community News

Civic journalism from Kalapuya lands in the Upper Willamette watershed

Oakridge, Westfir: Quarry would wreck our growing recreation economy

17 min read
Louis Pokorny: My wife and I are opposed to setting up rock crushers up there and blasting and making that country ugly, as that's what it is. I've seen them before and they are ugly.

Oakridge and Westfir residents ask Lane County not to foul up the area’s world-class recreation with an obsolete, decade-old application for a quarry they call ‘corruption in plain sight.’ Oakridge City Administrator James Cleavenger:

James Cleavenger Why you would vote for supporting this application when nobody wants it—City Council doesn’t want it, the people don’t want it—it befuddles me.

But there are approximately 250,000 reasons you might support it. And I’m referring to the campaign contributions to Commissioners Farr, Ceniga, and Loveall. And frankly I think this is corruption in plain sight, and you should be ashamed of yourselves. And I have no idea how you sleep at night. (Applause)

Commissioner Ryan Ceniga Thank you for your public comment. All right.

Josh Laughlin My name is Josh Laughlin. I’d like to reiterate this process, like the Jones-McCann debacle up River continues to stink of cronyism, and that money alone can buy Lane County Board of Commissioners decision that benefit the wealthy class. (Applause)

Commissioner Ryan Ceniga All right, that’s enough. We’re going to keep this respectful, please. So no clapping so we can get through all our public testimony we have today.

Guen DiGioia I’m Guen DiGioia and I’m the city planner for the city of Oakridge. I believe that approving something like this is really only going to stunt the community.

Edwin Weih I am Edwin Weih, Oakridge, Oregon. I practiced medicine in Oakridge from 1992 to 2022 for approximately eight years. My family practice was the only medical care in town.

The town of Oakridge sits in a bowl surrounded by mountains. The only escape for trapped air is down Highway 58 towards I-5. During my first ten years of practice, the winter smoke and smog would cause a huge increase in surge in COPD, asthma, bronchitis and pneumonia.

LRAPA, through hard work and partnerships, changed our poor atmospheric quality. They exchanged inefficient wood stoves for new, cleaner burning stoves. They promoted the use of dry firewood and installed many ductless HVAC units.

I saw a tremendous drop in winter respiratory problems due to the changes LRAPA helped bring about.

Having 86 trucks of silica-laden rock rolling through town undoubtedly will bring these respiratory issues back. There will also be the added horrible problem of lung silicosis.

I respectfully request that you do not change the land use for the TV Butte area. Thank you for your attention.

Jara Mouracade Jara Mouracade, Westfir city councilor. A Westfir business owner and a resident of the city of Oakridge.

Westfir has just under 300 residents and is the smallest incorporated city in Lane County. It’s home to the longest covered bridge in all of Oregon—Office Covered Bridge—and world-class mountain biking that brings thousands of visitors and visitor dollars to Lane County every year. Westfir relies on tourism as the only economic driver in our community.

The damage that the proposed quarry would inflict on our community would be detrimental to not only the residents of Westfir, but our visitors that are attracted to the clean, quiet, remote wilderness environment.

Imagine tying on a fly and casting your rod into the pristine waters of the North Fork of the Willamette River, only to be disrupted by the sounds of dozens of gravel trucks barreling down the highway.

Imagine you and your family are enjoying a lovely Sunday hike on one of the dozens of trails in the Westfir area, only to be cut short due to the harmful particulate matter in the air, causing your daughter to have an asthma attack.

Imagine a fire raging through your neighborhood, but the local fire department doesn’t have enough water to fight the fire due to the mine pulling water from the aquifer that supplies water to your town.

These are real scenarios that could happen if you allowed this rezoning to occur. The residents and visitors of Westfir deserve better. Alongside the city of Oakridge, the city of Westfir remains in opposition of any and all efforts to rezone TV Butte to allow for mining and gravel operations.

I would like to present the city of Westfir Resolution No. 588, Opposition to TV Butte Rezoning and Mining Operations and in support of the city of Oakridge, Resolution 15-2026.

Oakridge resident: I live in Oakridge, and I’ve been involved with this process since the beginning.

And at the beginning, neighbors of that area took me on a walk along the railroad tracks up the hill where the dump site was, and I saw multiple containers sticking out all over the place. They were dumped there by the lumber industry when it was still being used as a dump site.

And I actually have pictures I didn’t bring with me, I had presented them years ago, and I only saw a small portion of that dump site, but there was lots of stuff sticking out everywhere and that had been closed for a long time. So it’s not going away.

And any quarry there would also kill the fish hatchery, which is really important and I encourage you to deny this application.

Jennifer Eisele  Jennifer Eisele, I am the communities and ecosystems project manager from Beyond Toxics, 120 Shelton McMurphey Blvd., Eugene.

Beyond Toxics is a statewide environmental justice advocacy organization, and we have significant concerns about the health risks to the community of Oakridge that this proposed project will generate.

Air quality and increased 2PM particulate matter to the airshed. Um, and no way to distinguish via monitoring whether the silica crystal from the dust created from the quarry will, um, there’s no way to differentiate Between wildfire smoke or wood heating, smoke and pollutants from the quarry.

Silica dust is known to cause lung cancer, emphysema, chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases, kidney and other autoimmune diseases. That will contribute to health risks to the community of Oakridge. We’re also concerned about the aforementioned aquifer study and the potential to harm the drinking water resources of the community.

We believe the permit must be denied under Oregon Administrative Rule, because the applicant has failed to address the conflicts that will arise due to noise, dust and other discharges, and the staff report fails to do so, not citing the conditions placed on the permit.

So we have submitted written comments for the record and urge that the permit be denied. Thank you.

Andrew Simrin My name is Andrew Simrin. I’m here today to oppose the rezoning of the TV Butte area.

I often visit the area because it’s got a trailhead to U.S. Forest Service land. And my understanding is the applicant hasn’t provided a traffic impact analysis by a third party. Um, and the current federal administration is looking to rescind travel management plans along U.S. Forest Service trails, including the Eugene to Crest Trail that’s along Dunning Road, has a trailhead there.

And so we could expect to see increased usage of bikes, potential e-bikes because it’s a very popular spot for mountain biking. That’s why I often visit the area despite moving from Eugene.

The applicant has had plenty of time to address the multitude of concerns brought by the community, including big game. And the applicant should prepare an ESEE report, as evidenced that the significant impacts cannot be minimized.

I enjoyed visiting the area because of the several times I’ve gone, I’ve seen the big elk there and it’s really cool to see that. And I think it’s part of the tourism of the area being able to, to see wildlife there in that area reliably. I think that’s a real asset to Lane County and a great reason why we should protect that Goal 5 resource and deny the application. Thank you.

Kim Fresenburg Kim Fresenburg, Oakridge. Do not gamble with Oakridge’s air, drinking water, financial future. Oakridge is historically ranked among the 20 worst communities in the U.S. for air quality. Our basin- shaped valley traps pollution during atmospheric inversions, making additional emissions of particular concern.

Blasting, crushing and heavy truck traffic deserve rigorous scrutiny in a community already burdened with air pollution. The county should assess their cumulative impacts, not evaluate the quarry as though it would operate in an otherwise clean airshed.

We have made meaningful progress and we should not put that progress at risk. Drinking water presents an even more consequential concern because damage could be irreversible. The former Dunning Road landfill lies near the property’s western boundary, which is just three hundred and sixty five feet from the city’s aquifer protection zone.

The CU identified the possibility of hazardous material, but the landfill’s contents and extent of contamination remain uncertain.

The University of Oregon’s preliminary assessment also raised concerns about the landfill, and there is no guarantee that they’ll be able to restore the aquifer of contaminated groundwater. Remediation is expensive, complex, and takes decades. The damage to our community and our health could far outlast the quarry itself.

The potential consequences extend beyond public health. If Oakridge’s municipal water supply were compromised, the city would face significant emergency water supply costs for a small city. These obligations would overwhelm available resources and could threaten Oakridge’s financial viability.

Before approving this, ask whether this is an appropriate location for a quarry, whether the claimed need justifies the risk, and whether enforceable protections would actually safeguard the community.

Ask yourself: Would any reasonable person think that this is a good idea?

Mick Garvin My name is Mick Garvin. It’s not good to be here. It’s not good to see you. It’s been ten years of not good to see you so far. I anticipate it will go longer than that.

Most of what I have to say has been said better by other people, but I want to know how, when I haven’t seen one person show up here or in Oakridge, one of these hearings in favor of this thing since, oh, years back, somebody from a Eugene sand and gravel operation came in and took a swing.

And you have all these people and all the people up where I live and a bunch of other recreationists saying, ‘This idea sucks.’

And how do you claim to represent a constituency of Lane County when it seems the people you are representing are Ed King and a bunch of investors?’  And I really would like you to take down my address and send me your answer to that.

Nancy Callaghan Hello, my name is Nancy Callaghan. I lived in Oakridge, Westfir, from 1977, and I was a teacher at the elementary school for over 30 years. And when I retired in 2011.

So I’ve been there many, many years part of the time, living there part of the time. Commuting up Highway 58, my last few years of teaching after moving down to this area.

I can tell you how really dangerous Highway 58 is 50 miles up and back every single day for years. We saw accidents that you wouldn’t believe on that road. I’m sure you’ve all heard of them.

But when I first moved there back in 1977, Oakridge was a thriving place. I’m sure you’ve all heard the stories about how there was a skating rink, there was a gas station, there was a grocery store. Everything was happening good there.

And then, of course, came the big downturn. And they’ve been struggling, excuse me, struggling ever since, trying to come back and are finally making some progress as time goes by by them With their tourism and biking projects that they’re working on, and just trying to be a sustainable community. This project that you’re considering here once again threatens this progress that’s been made over the years.

The pollution alone, air pollution that they already struggle with, with smoke and fire. Then this dust and noise and water potential, every single kind of pollution that there is, according to also the pollution of the culture and the livelihood of people up there who just want to have a decent community to live in.

I was reading that Eugene Springfield ranks fourth in the United States—

Commissioner Ryan Ceniga Thank you for your public comment.

Nancy Callaghan: —worst in pollution. So we do not need to add anything else to that.

Ben Olson Ben Olson, Oakridge. I want to thank all my fellow citizens from Oakridge for showing up. We’ve been doing this for 10 years. This has dragged on and and we are passionate about making sure that there’s not going to be a quarry in Oakridge. And we will continue to do this as long as we have to.

My concern is that if the applicant is wrong on any of the criteria that they had to meet to get this quarry in there that we’re going to be living with the results for the next 50 years. Our generation, our children, our grandchildren are all going to have to live with the fallout.

These quarries don’t get shut down. They continue to operate, and the citizens end up having to deal with the impact of that. And I think that’s what everybody in our town is, is afraid of that. It’s not going to be as they describe it. I think this is a terrible idea to have this quarry right next to our town there in Oakridge. Thank you.

Mark Robinowitz Mark Robinowitz. I’ll be quick.

I’m calling for the recusal of any commissioners who took contributions from anyone involved with the strip mine. A judge who took money from someone before their court would be committing an impeachable offense. Oakridge citizens should be allowed to vote on this project. You have the city of Oakridge logo on your dais, and I hope you will listen to them.

The quarry will not be posting a financial bond in case they harm the public, despite their promises. And if this is such a wonderful idea, why not propose similar operations for Santa Clara (Commissioner Farr’s district), in West Lane or the middle of Springfield?

Since it’s so wonderful and if this goes ahead, the mine should be required to do a sustainable mining practice. Just mine the ore at the same rate it’s formed—you’ll have jobs for eons.

And it’s also worth noting the obvious and blatant differences in gender versus the positions on the board. That speaks very loudly. Thank you.

Ellen Komp My name is Ellen Komp. I live in Oakridge. I’m part of the I understand 50% of our population that are seniors. I’ve been coming there for the last several years after working very hard since the age of 16, hoping that beautiful Oakridge would be a place where I could retire.

I was attracted by the beautiful forest in the area, the peaceful, the clean air and water. And now you’re looking at ruining all of that, ruining the economic viability of the area because it depends on tourism as well as the health and safety of the wildlife and the people who live there.

I beg you not to do this to our community, which also includes a lot of wonderful artists, musicians, young families.

So much more could be done with the area with resource input rather than resource extraction. Thank you.

Dan Ernst  Dan Ernst. Okay. I’d like to keep things simple. So the purchaser of the property had full disclosure that it was forest land.

But then maybe they had enough money, they said, ‘Oh, we can overcome that. Politics these days, it’s about doing favors.’

Seriously, if you vote for this thing, I think that’s what we’re going to have to say, that some of these politicians that have received money are doing favors, and that’s sinful. Thank you.

Elise O’Brien Hello. My name is Elise O’Brien. I’m a resident in Westfir, and I have to echo mixed sentiment that I am not happy to be here. I’m a grad student and I am taking time away from the time I should be on campus to come and speak to you.

We are a poor community. Our income level is about half of the rest of Oregon. The land that we have is our wealth. What you’re doing is you’re asking to take away what we do have. This quarry is already negatively impacting our economy.

Many of us should probably be at work right now, but we are having to take the time out to come here. We do not have an extra $250,000 to fight this. Our community has been raising money through bake sales, raffle prizes.

Might I suggest that if Ed King needs a quarry so badly that he might think about siting it on his biodynamic vineyard? (Applause)

Commissioner Ryan Ceniga Thank you. Okay, this is the last warning. There will be no more clapping and whooping and hollering or you’ll be asked to leave the meeting. Okay? Let’s keep it respectful.

Phil Robbins My name is Phil Robbins. I am speaking in opposition to the changes in the rural comprehensive plan, and also all of the rezoning that has been mentioned.

Until three years ago, I lived with my family on a small farm in Dexter. We grew organic produce and strawberries. We participated in the local farmers market, the Dexter Lake Farmers Market, which is no longer. And part of the reason it is no longer is because I left. We also had a thriving CSA operation.

We lived, unfortunately, a quarter of a mile from Parvin Butte, and as I watched our former County Commissioner Faye Stewart took the lead in forcing the Parvin Butte mountaintop removal gravel mining operation, against the objections of the people of Dexter.

The truth was an early victim of that process. I spent many hours in this room, all for nothing.

The blasting and vibration from the mine led to short circuits in the wiring inside our walls. Cracks developed in our masonry. When the wind was right, we had dust. The incessant grinding, clattering noise of the rock crusher could be heard all over the valley and was extremely irritating.

And as a person who is hard of hearing and has tinnitus, it wasn’t very helpful for my situation.

Gen Schaack My name is Gen and I’ve had the pleasure of working with the Oakridge community over many of the last years, whether it was providing logistical support to wildland firefighting crews through the support of the acquisition of Kitson Hot Springs in my role at the Upper Willamette Soil and Water Conservation District.

A lot of people have said very important things here today that I will let them say, but I’m actually here today to talk as a former math teacher.

I read through—well, I skimmed the application and there’s only 16.9 million tons of gravel there. If you sell those for $100 per ton, that only comes to $126,750,000.

And then if you take that and you take the average cost of a human life valued at $7.5 million, that number is then met when 22.5 people die.

And I’d like the commissioners to imagine how swiftly we will meet that metric with the threat of pollution from the silica in the caldera, with the increased traffic on 58, which is a known dangerous highway.

This is bad for business. It does not add up. And with such a profound public outcry against it from the people who will be impacted by this, I’m really disappointed that we’re even having this conversation.

I’d like to thank everyone who has spoken before me and said such brilliant things, and those who will go after…

Even the demand for that gravel is based in 1995. So like super outdated, not reasonable to see any benefit in this project.

Jill Mardin Jill Mardin. I have been a resident here for a little over 20 years. I turned 70 when all of this first started and I just had my 80th birthday, and it’s breaking my heart that here we still are.

And for all the reasons that all of my amazing (I’m going to cry) wonderful friends and neighbors have stated after driving once again down to the valley to have to give testimony. And I seriously want to thank all of you who are there. I can’t see you, but I hear you. I know who you are and I love you and thank you.

As for my testimony today, it hasn’t changed at all since the last few times that I gave it. Except I would like to add one thing, and I know it’s going to sound silly, but it’s very real.

About four nights ago, my neighbor, whom I share a driveway with, caught on his Ring camera a mama bear and two cubs standing outside his front door, about 10 feet away from my house.

And the reason I’m saying this is because what’s happening here, because of the fires, the smoke and all, you know, all of that, our critters who are a vital part of our ecosystem are losing habitat and it’s getting worse all the time.

Cyma Lovell-Beers: My name is Cyma Lovell-Beers. I moved up here in June of 2018 and immediately fell in love with Oakridge. Oakridge knows that they have my full support.

This is a horrible, horrible, bad idea. After the logging company left, Oakridge looked around and they said, ‘Let’s use what we got.’ And they did.

We’re number six on the planet for mountain biking. People come up here just to look at the stars. I’ve seen the Milky Way.

We as a community cannot let this happen. And being that the applicant has such a big spread, from what I understand on Lorane Highway, which is a gorgeous area, why don’t he go and do this out there?

You know, that’s where he is. He got his vineyard and everything. Don’t come and mess up our stuff. That Oakridge has fought long, hard. They got creative and they did it. We’re on our way. Leave us alone. Go do it someplace else. And that’s all I have to say. Thank you.

Louis Pokorny I didn’t take Dale Carnegie, so forgive me. My name is Louis Pokorny. I live east of Oakridge, on the east side of TV Butte.

Rock pits are ugly and they’re dirty. I can say that I know about them. My wife and I are opposed to setting up rock crushers up there and blasting and making that country ugly, as that’s what it is. I’ve seen them before and they are ugly.

We have deer, elk and bear. Bear wake me up, 3 in the morning, in an apple tree. And it says, Leave us alone over here.

Anyway. I just want to say something today that’s probably never been brought up about TV Butte. That little bump right there, we call Johnny Hill. I know it sounds whacked out, but we call it Johnny Hill. You cross the railroad tracks from there on up that road, that’s Johnny Hill.

The reason is, back in 1961, my first cousin when I was 11 was driven over by a garbage truck from the city of Oakridge in those days, but I never forgot where I was standing when I was told that.

This is kind of different off a TV Butte story, but when I hear TV Butte, I have memories of Charlie Tufti, Chuck, Chuck, the Indians that were living up there when my folks moved here in the late thirties. Raymond Dunning, which the Dunning Road was named after, that lived on the old house, clear at the end of the road. I was there when I was this big.

Somehow it got into the Palaniuk family, and I remember going into the old house where the black was on the ceilings from the kerosene lamps and the wood cookstove. They didn’t have electricity and the gas-powered washing machine and those kind of things.

But anyway, I just want to mention that we still call it Johnny Hill up there when you cross the tracks…

John Q: Public comments Oct. 20 say Oakridge and Westfir have built a recreation-based economy, and suggest to the commissioners: Why don’t you go somewhere else?

Copyright © All rights reserved. Newsphere by AF themes.